TranscriptLab vs YouTubeScribe: Free cache hits + audio STT.
Two-sentence verdict
Pick YouTubeScribe if you want unlimited free manual TXT/SRT browser downloads or 116 free creator utilities. Pick TranscriptLab for production API & MCP work: cached reads cost 0 credits (not 1), workspace AI summaries use 0 transcript credits, and audio STT handles captionless videos.
Why teams switch from YouTubeScribe
Verified product limits, pricing tiers, and workflow gaps checked on 2026-11-18.
| Trigger | YouTubeScribe | TranscriptLab | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cached API responses still burn credits | `X-Cache-Status: HIT` responses still cost 1 credit per call ("Cached responses still cost a credit") | First delivery of a variant costs 1 credit; every repeat GET of an owned variant is free | YouTubeScribe Docs |
| Production API & MCP endpoint URLs in docs | Live `/docs` page prints placeholder `https://api.localhost` and `https://mcp.localhost` URLs | Production REST (`https://api.transcriptlab.dev`), MCP (`/mcp`), and OpenAPI 3.1 Swagger docs | YouTubeScribe Docs |
| Missing captions & audio/video transcription | Captions-only ("no workaround is offered" when a video has no caption track) | Explicit engine=stt for captionless videos plus /v1/media & 2 GB file uploads with diarization | YouTubeScribe Pricing |
| AI summaries & VTT/JSON export gating | VTT, Markdown, and JSON web exports require Pro ($49.99/yr); AI summaries cost 12 credits, chat costs 8 credits | TXT, SRT, VTT, and JSON exports included for every user; workspace AI summary/chapters/chat use 0 transcript credits | YouTubeScribe Pricing |
| Async 250-video batches & x402 agent payments | Single-video REST endpoints plus playlist/channel pagination; no x402 USDC rail | Batch & channel jobs up to 250 videos with webhooks + x402 ($0.01/transcript) | YouTubeScribe Docs |
Pricing math at real volume
Monthly cost based on the tier each volume forces you onto—rounded in neither direction.
| Monthly volume | YouTubeScribe plan + cost | TranscriptLab plan + cost | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1,000 API calls (50% cache hits) | 1,000 credits consumed (cache hits still cost 1 credit) | 500 credits consumed ($3.99/mo Starter covers 2x workload) | Free repeat variant reads cut credit burn |
| 100 AI video summaries/mo | 1,200 AI credits (Pro $49.99/yr + $2.49 top-up) | Included on Free (10 credits) or Starter ($3.99/mo) | 0 extra transcript credits for AI summaries |
| Manual browser TXT / SRT extracts | $0 unlimited in browser (no account) | $0 (3 guest/mo, 10 on free account) | YouTubeScribe wins unlimited manual browser pulls |
Based on YouTubeScribe pricing and API docs (checked 2026-11-18): Pro $49.99/yr, Studio $129.99/yr, 12 credits/summary, 8 credits/chat message, and 1 credit per cached API hit. Check live YouTubeScribe pricing · View TranscriptLab pricing.
Switch from YouTubeScribe in 10 minutes
Swap the endpoint and auth header, then test one video directly or via the free YouTube Transcript Generator.
Step 1: Create a TranscriptLab API key.
Sign in for 10 free credits and grab a ytgw_ key in /dashboard/keys.
Step 2: Point transcript requests to https://api.transcriptlab.dev/v1/transcripts.
Request JSON, TXT, SRT, or VTT directly on the REST endpoint instead of converting segments client-side.
Step 3: Re-read cached variants via GET /v1/transcripts/{videoId} for free.
Save storage complexity—owned transcript variants cost 0 credits on repeat GET calls.
curl -X POST "https://api.transcriptlab.dev/v1/transcripts" \
-H "Authorization: Bearer $YTGW_KEY" \
-H "Content-Type: application/json" \
-d '{"video_id":"dQw4w9WgXcQ","format":"vtt","lang":"en"}'Where YouTubeScribe is the better choice
TranscriptLab is built specifically for YouTube transcripts, media speech-to-text, and developer/agent pipelines. Choose YouTubeScribe instead if your stack relies on:
- Unlimited free manual browser TXT, SRT, and PDF downloads with no account and no daily cap.
- 116 free web tools covering channel stats, comment exporters, and creator calculators.
- YouTube search, channel uploads, RSS latest (Free), and playlist pagination endpoints at 300 RPM.
Frequently asked questions
Does TranscriptLab charge a credit on cache hits like YouTubeScribe?
No. TranscriptLab charges 1 credit the first time your account receives a transcript variant; repeat reads of that same variant via GET /v1/transcripts/{videoId} cost 0 credits.
Is VTT export free on TranscriptLab?
Yes. Every TranscriptLab user—including guest pulls and free accounts—can export TXT, SRT, VTT, and JSON without upgrading to an annual plan.
What if I want unlimited free manual downloads in a browser?
Use YouTubeScribe for unlimited single-video browser pulls. Use TranscriptLab when you need an API, free cached re-reads, audio speech-to-text, MCP, or x402 agent payments.
Does TranscriptLab charge credits for AI summaries or Ask AI?
No. In the TranscriptLab workspace, creating summaries, timestamped chapters, or asking AI questions on a saved transcript uses zero transcript credits.
More TranscriptLab comparisons
See all comparisonsReady to switch
from YouTubeScribe?
Start with 10 free credits or try our live YouTube Transcript Generator without signing in.