TranscriptLab vs TubeAlfred: $3.99 MCP + audio STT.
Two-sentence verdict
Pick TubeAlfred if you need 34 YouTube MCP tools—including YouTube comment extraction—or 5,000–12,000 caption-only calls/mo at $15–$29. Pick TranscriptLab if you want a $3.99/mo starter plan, $4.99 top-up packs that do not expire monthly, explicit audio STT for captionless videos, SRT/VTT exports, and x402 payments.
Why teams switch from TubeAlfred
Verified product limits, pricing tiers, and workflow gaps checked on 2026-11-18.
| Trigger | TubeAlfred | TranscriptLab | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum paid subscription tier | Creator Plus starts at $15/mo (5,000 credits); no ~$4/mo entry tier | Starter starts at $3.99/mo (1,000 credits) or $4.99 one-time pack | TubeAlfred Pricing |
| Unused credit expiration | Free credits and monthly subscription credits expire at period end with no rollover | $4.99 one-time Credit packs stack on any plan with no monthly subscription needed | TubeAlfred Pricing |
| Captionless videos & audio/video files | Captions-only ("Transcripts require available captions") — no STT or media upload | Explicit engine=stt for YouTube audio plus POST /v1/media and dashboard uploads (up to 2 GB) | TubeAlfred |
| SRT/VTT exports, speaker diarization & regex search | Read-only transcript/metadata/comment tools without diarized STT or SRT/VTT format options | Outputs JSON, TXT, SRT, and VTT; supports speaker labels (`diarize=true`) and regex/chunk search | TubeAlfred Pricing |
| Autonomous agent billing (x402) | Subscription credits + OAuth/API key only; no public uptime SLA | Supports x402 USDC on Base ($0.01/transcript) with zero account or API key | TubeAlfred Pricing |
Pricing math at real volume
Monthly cost based on the tier each volume forces you onto—rounded in neither direction.
| Monthly volume | TubeAlfred plan + cost | TranscriptLab plan + cost | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1,000 transcripts/mo | Creator Plus ($15.00/mo, 5,000 credits) | Starter ($3.99/mo, 1,000 credits) | TranscriptLab saves $132.12/yr |
| 3,000 transcripts/mo | Creator Plus ($15.00/mo, 5,000 credits) | Starter + 2 packs ($13.97/mo) | TranscriptLab saves $12.36/yr |
| 5,000 transcripts/mo | Creator Plus ($15.00/mo, 5,000 credits) | Starter + 4 packs ($23.95/mo) | TubeAlfred saves $107.40/yr at 5k/mo |
Based on TubeAlfred pricing page (checked 2026-11-18): Creator Plus $15/mo (5,000 credits) and Creator Pro $29/mo (12,000 credits). Check live TubeAlfred pricing · View TranscriptLab pricing.
Switch from TubeAlfred in 5 minutes
Swap the endpoint and auth header, then test one video directly or via the free YouTube Transcript Generator.
Step 1: Add the TranscriptLab MCP URL in Claude, ChatGPT, or Cursor.
Use https://api.transcriptlab.dev/mcp with OAuth 2.0 dynamic client registration or a ytgw_ API key.
Step 2: Call transcriptlab_get_transcript or search your library.
Fetch captions, run regex/chunk searches, and export 10-minute TXT/SRT/VTT download links inside your chat.
Step 3: Use transcriptlab_transcribe_file for audio without captions.
Attach MP3/MP4 recordings or pass a public HTTPS media URL with optional speaker diarization.
claude mcp add --transport http transcriptlab https://api.transcriptlab.dev/mcpWhere TubeAlfred is the better choice
TranscriptLab is built specifically for YouTube transcripts, media speech-to-text, and developer/agent pipelines. Choose TubeAlfred instead if your stack relies on:
- 34 YouTube MCP and REST tools including YouTube comments (1 credit per 20 comments, 5-credit min) and hosted comment exports.
- 50 free credits resetting monthly on the free tier without a credit card.
- Lower unit price at 5,000–12,000 caption-only calls/mo ($15/mo Creator Plus, $29/mo Creator Pro).
Frequently asked questions
How does TranscriptLab MCP differ from TubeAlfred MCP?
TubeAlfred focuses on broad read-only YouTube research across 34 tools including comments. TranscriptLab focuses on transcript retrieval, regex/chunk search, SRT/VTT exports, and audio/video speech-to-text with speaker labels.
Which is cheaper if I use fewer than 3,000 transcripts per month?
TranscriptLab is cheaper up to ~3,000/month: Starter is $3.99/month for 1,000 credits ($13.97/month for 3,000), whereas TubeAlfred’s lowest paid plan is $15/month.
Can TubeAlfred transcribe a video that has no captions?
No. TubeAlfred states that transcripts require available captions. TranscriptLab lets you transcribe captionless YouTube videos (engine=stt) and uploaded audio/video files.
Can I share or export formatted subtitles from TranscriptLab?
Yes. Both the REST API and MCP server support TXT, SRT, VTT, Markdown, and JSON exports.
More TranscriptLab comparisons
See all comparisonsReady to switch
from TubeAlfred?
Start with 10 free credits or try our live YouTube Transcript Generator without signing in.